Expert DirectoryHow We WorkInsightsAuthority NetworkAboutFind an Expert
Personal Injury & Liability

Premises Liability Expert Witness

Vident Partners provides vetted premises liability expert witnesses for cases involving dangerous conditions, notice and inspection failures, stairs and walkways, building code violations, property maintenance and injuries to invitees and children nationwide. Request a referral today.

Find a Premises Liability Expert →

About Premises Liability Expert Witnesses

A premises liability expert decides whether a condition on the property was unreasonably dangerous, whether the owner knew or should have known about it, and what a reasonable owner would have done. The law supplies the duty. The expert supplies the facts about what was wrong and how buildings are normally run. Most cases come down to notice, and that means the maintenance record.

This page covers the general field: the condition, the property and its management. Slips and falls on a walking surface have their own page, with their own test methods. Criminal attacks on a property belong to negligent security. Liquor service belongs to dram shop.

What the Expert Does in a Case

The expert usually wants to see the site. A good inspection records the condition as it was, with measurements and photographs, and compares it with the condition on the date of injury. The file typically includes:

  • Inspection logs, maintenance tickets and repair invoices
  • Incident reports and prior complaints for the same location
  • The lease, showing who controlled the area
  • Building permits, code citations and as-built drawings
  • Video from the day, which is often overwritten quickly and should be demanded early
  • Property management policies and vendor contracts, such as for snow removal or janitorial work

The Legal Frame the Expert Works Within

The duty owed depends on the state, and often on why the person was on the property. An invitee is someone who enters with the owner's express or implied invitation, and the typical duty is reasonable care to keep the premises reasonably safe and to warn of known dangerous conditions that are not open and obvious 1. Other entrants traditionally get less protection. Children are a special case: the attractive nuisance doctrine addresses a dangerous condition that may particularly attract children 2. Some jurisdictions have moved away from the old categories. In Kermarec v. Compagnie Generale Transatlantique, the Supreme Court rejected them on a ship, holding that the owner owes a duty of reasonable care under the circumstances to those aboard for purposes not inimical to its interests 3. An expert should be given the forum's rule and should not state the law.

The Standards That Get Used

Evidence of what was reasonable comes from several places. Experts should separate what was legally binding from what was simply good practice.

  • Building and fire codes. The code adopted locally, in the edition that applied when the building was built or changed. Older buildings are often lawful under an earlier code, so a violation of the current edition may prove nothing
  • Accessibility. The 2010 ADA Standards for Accessible Design set requirements for covered facilities 4. Under 28 CFR 36.211, a public accommodation must keep required accessible features in operable working condition 5
  • Workplace rules. OSHA's general rule requires that walking-working surfaces be inspected regularly and as necessary, and kept in a safe condition 6. It protects employees, but it is often cited as evidence of a reasonable inspection practice
  • Consensus standards. ASTM, ANSI and industry standards can show what a careful owner would know, even where no law adopts them

Where the Fight Usually Is

  • Notice. Actual knowledge, or how long the condition existed before the injury
  • Inspection. Whether a reasonable inspection would have found it, and whether inspections really took place
  • Open and obvious. Whether the danger was one a person would see, and whether something drew attention away from it
  • Control. Owner, tenant, manager or contractor
  • Code and causation. Whether a code violation actually caused this injury, or was only present
  • Remediation. Whether a repair after the event can be used, which is a question of evidence rules

Background

Attorneys retain them to evaluate compliance with building codes, ADA requirements, and recognized property-management standards, and to determine whether hazards were open, concealed, or reasonably foreseeable 4. These experts review inspection and maintenance records, incident history, and the physical condition of the property to opine on the owner's notice of the hazard and the adequacy of remediation 7. Their analysis addresses the standard of care owed to invitees, licensees, and other entrants under common-law and statutory frameworks applicable to commercial and residential premises 8.

Who Is Qualified

Match the witness to the condition. An architect or code consultant addresses design and code. An experienced property manager addresses inspection routines and vendors. An engineer addresses structures or mechanical failures. A human factors expert addresses what a person would see and do. Beware of the all-purpose safety witness who will give an opinion on any condition. Courts test whether experience fits the specific hazard, and a report that rests only on general experience is exposed under Rule 702.

The typical duty to an invitee is reasonable care to keep the premises reasonably safe and to warn of known dangerous conditions that are not open and obvious.

SourcedResearched by Vident Partners, with sources below. Editorial standardsLast updated

Common Case Types

Falls from stairs, ramps, balconies and handrails

Defective doors, gates and walkways

Falling objects in stores and warehouses

Inadequate lighting and hidden hazards

Injuries to children and attractive nuisance

Pools, recreational areas and common areas

Code violations in older buildings

Accessible route and maintenance failures

Stairway, railing, and structural hazard falls

Qualifications to Look For

  • Direct experience with the condition at issue, whether in design, code or management
  • Architect, engineer or code official credentials where the opinion is technical
  • Experience inspecting and maintaining the same kind of property
  • Working knowledge of the code edition that applied
  • Ability to document a site with measurements and photographs
  • Prior deposition or trial testimony on premises conditions

Frequently Asked Questions

What qualifications should a premises liability expert witness have?

The expert's experience should fit the specific condition: an architect or code official for design, a property manager for inspection, an engineer for mechanical or structural failures. General safety experience alone may not hold up. Hands-on experience inspecting or managing properties and prior testimony experience are important.

Does a building code violation prove liability?

Not by itself. The expert must show that the code applied to this building at that time, and that the violation contributed to the injury. Older buildings are often lawful under earlier codes.

What is notice?

Notice means the owner knew about the condition, or should have known because it existed long enough for a reasonable inspection to find it. It usually comes down to the inspection and maintenance record.

What does open and obvious mean?

It refers to a danger a reasonable person would see. Its effect varies by state. Experts may address what was visible and what distracted the person, but the legal effect is for the court.

Why should evidence be demanded quickly?

Video is often overwritten and conditions get repaired. An early preservation letter, followed by a prompt site inspection, gives the expert the record needed.

What types of cases require a premises liability expert?

These experts are retained in cases involving injuries from dangerous property conditions, inadequate maintenance, structural and stairway hazards, and code or accessibility violations. They help establish the standard of care owed and whether the owner had notice of the hazard.

How much does a premises liability expert witness cost?

In general, expert fees are determined by the expert themselves, based on a variety of criteria. Among those criteria are professional experience, forensic and testimony experience, relevant certifications, case-type specialization, and publications. Vident does have some influence over expert fees by comparing experts within a specialty, but ultimately it is a personal decision by the expert.

Need a Premises Liability Expert Witness?

Vident Partners connects attorneys with qualified premises liability expert witnesses. Complimentary consultation, 24-hour turnaround, no obligation.

Request an Expert →