Expert DirectoryHow We WorkInsightsAuthority NetworkAboutFind an Expert
Personal Injury & Liability

Negligent Security Expert Witness

Vident Partners provides vetted negligent security expert witnesses for cases involving assaults, shootings and robberies at apartments, hotels, parking areas, hospitals, malls and campuses, and failures of guards, lighting and access control nationwide. Request a referral today.

Find a Negligent Security Expert →

About Negligent Security Expert Witnesses

A negligent security expert decides whether a crime on a property was foreseeable, what reasonable security would have looked like, and whether it would have made a difference. These cases are not about a perfect world. No property can stop every crime, and a good expert says so. The question is whether this owner knew of a risk, and did what a reasonable owner in that place would have done about it.

This page covers security practice on private property. Police conduct has its own pages. Hospital, school and workplace violence have related pages. Lighting design can call for a lighting expert, and a criminologist often addresses crime data.

What the Expert Does in a Case

The expert builds a crime history first: police calls for service, incident reports, security logs, tenant complaints and prior lawsuits. Next comes a site visit, ideally at the same hour and day of the week as the event, looking at lighting, sight lines, fences, locks, cameras and how people actually move through the place. The expert then reviews guard contracts, post orders, training and patrol records, budgets and any prior security assessment.

Calls for service are not the same as crimes. Many are unfounded or unrelated, so a report that simply counts them invites a challenge. The numbers should be sorted by type and location.

Foreseeability

The law varies by state, and the duty usually depends on foreseeability. Texas shows how specific this can get. The Fifth Circuit, applying Texas law, explained that courts first narrow the relevant criminal history, then compare it with the crime in question using the five Timberwalk factors: proximity, publicity, recency, frequency and similarity 1. In that case the question was whether a landowner owed a duty to protect against the criminal acts of third parties 1. Other states use a totality of the circumstances test, a prior similar incidents test, or a balancing test, so the expert should be told which rule applies and should not choose one.

The general duty often comes from an owner's relationship with invitees. It includes reasonable care to keep the premises reasonably safe 2.

Standards of Practice

There is no single national security code. Experts rely on a mix of sources and should be honest about their weight.

  • Crime prevention through environmental design. This is an accepted approach based on lighting, access and natural surveillance
  • Industry guidance. ASIS International issues guidelines, and its Certified Protection Professional credential is the field's best-known certificate
  • Regulators. OSHA guidelines cover violence in healthcare and social service settings, and they are advisory 3. Colleges must report crimes under 34 CFR 668.46 4
  • Guard licensing. Many states license guards and set training rules, so the question may be whether the contractor met them
  • The property's own promises. Advertising a gated community, or a lease promise of security, can set expectations

Where the Fight Usually Is

  • Foreseeability. How far away and how long ago prior crimes count
  • Causation. Whether a guard, a camera or better lighting would have stopped this crime, a question that is often the hardest part of the case. It is especially difficult with a determined attacker
  • Control. Owner, management company or security contractor
  • Neighborhood crime. Whether a high crime rate in the area alone creates a duty, which courts treat cautiously
  • Crime data. Whether commercial crime scores are reliable for a single address
  • Criminal fault. How a jury splits responsibility between the owner and the attacker, which depends on state law

The Bureau of Justice Statistics describes two measures of nonfatal violence, the Uniform Crime Reports and the National Crime Victimization Survey 5. National data of either kind does not establish the risk at one property.

Background

Negligent security experts evaluate whether a property owner implemented reasonable security measures in light of foreseeable criminal activity and recognized industry standards 6. These experts review police reports, prior incident data, premises layouts, and security policies to opine on the adequacy of the security program and the foreseeability of the crime. Their analysis applies recognized security-management practices such as those reflected in the ASIS International Certified Protection Professional (CPP) credential 8 and crime-prevention principles codified in ISO 22341:2021, the international standard for Crime Prevention Through Environmental Design (CPTED) 9. ISO 22341:2021 defines CPTED as the process for analysing and assessing crime and security risks to guide development, urban design, site management, and the use of the built environment in order to reduce crime and the fear of crime.

Who Is Qualified

Look for someone who has actually run security for that kind of property: a security director for a hospital, hotel group, apartment manager or mall. A former police officer is not automatically qualified. Police work and private security planning are different jobs, and cross-examination goes straight to that difference. Ask what security programs the expert has designed and managed. A criminologist can add rigor on crime patterns and displacement, but may not know how budgets and guard contracts really work.

Texas courts compare prior crimes with the event using five factors: proximity, publicity, recency, frequency and similarity.

SourcedResearched by Vident Partners, with sources below. Editorial standardsLast updated

Common Case Types

Apartment and residential complex assaults

Hotel and motel attacks

Parking lot and garage crimes

Shootings at malls, bars and nightclubs

Hospital and workplace violence

Campus and school attacks

Guard company negligence

Lighting, access control and camera failures

Inadequate lighting, fencing, or access-control claims

Insufficient or improperly trained security personnel

Qualifications to Look For

  • Experience running security for the same kind of property
  • Experience designing and managing security programs, not only police work
  • Certified Protection Professional or similar credential, where held
  • Ability to analyze crime data by type and location
  • Knowledge of the forum's foreseeability test
  • Experience with guard contracts, training and post orders
  • Prior deposition or trial testimony on security practices
  • Active experience in security assessment, crime-prevention design (CPTED), or security operations

Frequently Asked Questions

What qualifications should a negligent security expert witness have?

Look for someone who has actually run security for the same kind of property. Police experience alone may not fit, since private security planning is a different job. Hands-on experience in security assessment, crime-prevention design, or operations and prior testimony experience are important.

Must there have been prior crimes on the property?

It depends on the state. Some look at prior similar incidents, others at all of the circumstances. Texas uses five factors: proximity, publicity, recency, frequency and similarity.

How is causation shown?

The expert must explain how a specific measure, such as a guard or better lighting, would probably have stopped or reduced this crime. That is often the hardest part of the case.

Are calls for service the same as crimes?

No. Many calls are unrelated or unfounded. They should be sorted by type and location before they are used.

Who is responsible when a security contractor was hired?

It depends on the contract and on state law. Owners may keep responsibility, and contractors can have their own duty. The expert reads both the contract and the actual practice.

What types of cases require a negligent security expert?

These experts are retained in cases involving assaults, robberies, or other crimes on premises where security may have been inadequate, including apartments, hotels, parking lots, and retail stores. They help establish whether the crime was foreseeable and whether reasonable security measures were in place.

How much does a negligent security expert witness cost?

In general, expert fees are determined by the expert themselves, based on a variety of criteria. Among those criteria are professional experience, forensic and testimony experience, relevant certifications, case-type specialization, and publications. Vident does have some influence over expert fees by comparing experts within a specialty, but ultimately it is a personal decision by the expert.

Need a Negligent Security Expert Witness?

Vident Partners connects attorneys with qualified negligent security expert witnesses. Complimentary consultation, 24-hour turnaround, no obligation.

Request an Expert →