Vident Partners provides vetted pediatric surgery expert witnesses for cases involving missed appendicitis, testicular torsion, newborn surgery, hernia repair, trauma and surgical complications in children. Request a referral today.
Find a Pediatric Surgery Expert →Overview
A pediatric surgery expert decides whether a child's surgical problem was recognized in time and treated the way a reasonably careful surgeon would have treated it. Children cannot always describe what hurts, their disease moves fast and their margins are small, so timing is usually the core of the case. This page covers surgery on infants, children and adolescents. Emergency department triage belongs to a pediatric emergency medicine expert, heart surgery to a cardiothoracic surgeon, and a child's general medical care to a pediatrician.
The expert reads triage notes, growth charts, vital sign flowsheets, lab trends, imaging with the original files, operative reports, nursing notes, anesthesia records and discharge instructions. In a missed-diagnosis case, the sequence of visits and phone calls is often what matters most.
A national review of United States legal cases found 170 cases involving pediatric surgical conditions from 1965 to 2017. Appendicitis was the most common diagnosis 1. Cases frequently involved delayed or missed diagnoses or interventions at 45.9 percent, technical concerns at 35.9 percent, deaths at 26.5 percent and negligent perioperative care at 23.6 percent 1. Against surgeons, technical complication was the most common allegation, at 49.1 percent, while cases against nonsurgeons typically involved a delayed or missed diagnosis 1. In 39 percent of cases the result favored the defendant, in 35 percent the plaintiff, and 14 percent were split 1. Those are reported legal cases, so they show patterns and not how often errors happen.
A separate German study of 129 claims listed the most common reasons for a finding of error as surgical-technical errors, treatment delay, insufficient workup, incorrect diagnosis and incomplete consent 2. Trauma, inguinal hernia, circumcision, testicular torsion and acute abdomen were among the most frequent settings 2. Its legal system differs, but the list will look familiar to a United States practitioner.
A review of 203 pediatric appendicitis claims from 1984 to 2013 found failure or delay in diagnosis to be the most common cause, and that cases that went to trial ended in defense verdicts 67.5 percent of the time 3. Mortality occurred in 19.9 percent of those cases 3. Most of these claims start before a surgeon is called, in an emergency department or clinic, so the surgical expert usually addresses what would have happened with earlier referral. The questions include how long symptoms had lasted, whether imaging or observation was reasonable, what discharge instructions said and whether the outcome would have changed. Perforation in a young child can happen quickly, and a timeline has to be built from the records.
Some conditions leave little room. Testicular torsion is a clear example, since a delay can cost the testicle. A review from Türkiye of 82 Supreme Court decisions reported that all testicular torsion cases resulted in organ loss and half of the appendicitis cases resulted in death 5. Malrotation with volvulus in an infant, necrotizing enterocolitis in a newborn and incarcerated hernias raise similar questions: was the sign present, who saw it, and how fast did the surgeon respond once called? The opinion should separate what was knowable at each visit from what became obvious later. Hindsight is a real risk in these cases, and a careful expert addresses it directly.
Operative claims involve injury to adjacent structures, such as the vas deferens during hernia repair, bile duct injury, anastomotic leaks and retained items. A known complication is not automatically negligence. The expert reads the operative report for how the problem arose, whether it was recognized and what was done next. Circumcision injuries were prominent enough in the United States series that, together with appendicitis, they made up almost a third of cases 1.
Consent runs through the parents, and it should cover the options, including watching and waiting where that is reasonable. Teenagers add a further question of assent under state law.
Look for a board certified pediatric surgeon in active practice at the time of the events. The American Board of Surgery defines the specialty as diagnostic, operative and postoperative surgical care for children with congenital and acquired anomalies and diseases, and certification follows initial certification in general surgery and an accredited pediatric surgery program 4. If a general surgeon operated on an older child, ask whether the forum calls for the same field. A pediatric emergency physician may be needed for what should have happened before the surgical consult.
In a national review of 170 pediatric surgical legal cases, delayed or missed diagnoses or interventions appeared in 45.9 percent.
Case Types
Missed or delayed appendicitis in children
Delayed diagnosis of testicular torsion
Bowel obstruction, malrotation and volvulus
Newborn surgery and necrotizing enterocolitis
Inguinal hernia repair injuries
Circumcision injuries
Pediatric trauma surgery
Consent for parents and adolescents
Qualifications
Related Specialties
FAQ
Look for a board certified pediatric surgeon in active practice at the time of the events, with direct experience in the condition at issue. A pediatric emergency physician may be needed for what happened before the surgical consult.
No. In a review of 203 pediatric claims, failure or delay in diagnosis was the most common cause, and cases that reached trial ended in defense verdicts 67.5 percent of the time. The question is what was reasonable at each visit.
Both surgeons and nonsurgeons. In a national review, surgeons were most often accused of technical complications, while nonsurgeons typically faced claims of delayed or missed diagnosis.
Not automatically. The expert reads how the problem arose, whether it was recognized, and what was done next. A known risk that was handled properly differs from an avoidable injury.
Parents or guardians generally consent under state law. Consent should cover the options, including watching and waiting where reasonable. Adolescents raise further questions under state rules.
In general, pediatric surgery expert fees are determined by the expert themselves, based on a variety of criteria. Among those criteria are experience, the child's age and condition, the length of the record, imaging review and the amount of testimony. Vident does have some influence over expert fees by comparing experts within a specialty, but ultimately it is a personal decision by the expert.
Related Insights
Most of us have signed a hospital consent form without reading every word. A recent Vermont Supreme Court decision, Ford v. Polomsky, shows what can happen when a patient later says, "I never agreed t...
Practice Area IntelligenceOver the past several years I have reviewed medical charts for both insurance companies and pain clinics to determine if what has been recorded makes good medical sense and shows an appropriate level...
Research BriefingFentanyl, a synthetic opioid, was first developed by Dr. Paul Janssen in the 1960s. From its inception, it was designed to be fast-acting, highly potent, and more readily synthesized than naturally oc...
Sources
Vident Partners connects attorneys with qualified pediatric surgery expert witnesses. Complimentary consultation, 24-hour turnaround, no obligation.
Request an Expert →