Vident Partners provides vetted pediatric neurology expert witnesses for cases involving cerebral palsy causation, childhood stroke, seizures, developmental injury, meningitis and traumatic brain injury in children. Request a referral today.
Find a Pediatric Neurology Expert →Overview
A pediatric neurology expert decides what happened to a child's developing brain, when it happened, and what caused it. That question sits at the center of many of the largest cases in medicine: a birth injury claim, a missed stroke or infection, or a head injury whose effects may not be fully known for years. This page covers neurological disease and injury in infants, children and adolescents, including child neurology. Fetal monitoring during labor belongs to an obstetric or maternal-fetal medicine expert, newborn care to a neonatologist, and the child's future costs to a life care planner.
The expert examines the child if the case allows it, and reads birth records, cord gases, newborn imaging, EEGs, developmental assessments, school and therapy records and genetic testing. Timing is the hard part. An MRI pattern can often tell an expert more about when an injury occurred than the delivery room notes can.
Birth injury claims often depend on this expert. The dispute is whether a brain injury came from events during labor or from something earlier, such as a prenatal infection, a genetic disorder or a stroke before birth. A forensic review states the problem plainly: defense and plaintiff expert opinions on the cause and timing of injury are often polarized, because of a lack of established methodology for analysis 1. It proposes using umbilical cord and newborn blood gas values as objective evidence 1, though any such framework will be tested on the facts of the child in the case.
The National Institute of Neurological Disorders and Stroke points to causes well beyond delivery, including multiple births, infections during pregnancy and other risks 2. It also says that some complications during labor and delivery can act as warning signs because they might be the first sign of something that happened before birth, and that most children born in these conditions will not develop cerebral palsy 2. That is why a difficult delivery does not prove when the injury occurred. A strong opinion ties the MRI pattern, the newborn's course, labs and genetic testing together, and answers competing explanations one by one.
Seizures are often misread in both directions. Of one hundred twenty-seven children seen in a first seizure clinic, 74 percent had epileptic events, 24 percent had nonepileptic events and 2 percent could not be classified 3. Pediatricians were more likely to refer true epileptic events than emergency or family physicians 3. Thirty-eight percent of the children with seizures had a prior probable seizure, recognized by the referring physician in only one case 3. The authors conclude that diagnostic inaccuracy is common in first seizure 3.
In newborns the problem is sharper. A review says recognition of neonatal seizures remains problematic, particularly when clinicians rely only on clinical criteria, and that physicians should use synchronized video-EEG recordings to limit misdiagnosis and overtreatment 4. So a claim may turn on whether EEG was available and when it should have been obtained. Treatment raises its own questions, including drug side effects and when a child should have been referred for an evaluation.
Children have strokes, and they are easily missed. A published case report notes that pediatric patients with atypical stroke symptoms pose a diagnostic challenge 5. A child with sudden weakness, speech trouble or a severe headache may be sent home with a diagnosis of migraine or a virus. The expert looks at what was reported, what imaging was ordered and what treatment could have changed. The window for treatment and the evidence for it are narrower in children than in adults, so causation needs care. Meningitis, encephalitis and shunt failure raise similar timing questions.
Children keep developing, so an injury at age two may look different at age ten. A life care plan and a damages claim both depend on prognosis, and the pediatric neurologist usually supplies it: what the child will be able to do, how long the child will live and what care will be needed. A neuropsychologist's testing adds detail. Reports should separate the effect of the injury from prior conditions, family history and the limits of what current assessments can predict.
Look for a physician with board certification in neurology with special qualification in child neurology, who sees these conditions regularly. Hospital-based experience with newborn neurology matters in birth injury cases. Ask whether the expert testifies for both sides, because these cases can draw polarized opinions 1. A neuroradiologist usually reads the MRI, and a geneticist may be needed to address other causes.
A forensic review says defense and plaintiff expert opinions on the cause and timing of brain injury are often polarized, because of a lack of established methodology.
Case Types
Cerebral palsy and birth injury causation
Timing of neonatal brain injury
Missed pediatric stroke
Delayed diagnosis of meningitis or encephalitis
Seizure misdiagnosis and medication injury
Shunt failure in hydrocephalus
Pediatric traumatic brain injury
Prognosis and life expectancy for a brain-injured child
Qualifications
Related Specialties
FAQ
Look for a physician board certified in neurology with special qualification in child neurology, who sees the condition regularly. Birth injury cases call for newborn neurology experience. A neuroradiologist usually reads the MRI.
Often it gives important clues. The pattern on imaging, read with the newborn's course, labs and genetic testing, helps an expert separate injury around delivery from something earlier. It rarely fixes an exact hour.
No. NINDS says some complications during labor can be the first sign of something that happened before birth, and that most children born in these conditions will not develop cerebral palsy. Timing has to be shown.
Many events look like seizures and are not, and true seizures can go unrecognized. In a first seizure clinic, 24 percent of events were nonepileptic, and most prior seizures had been missed. In newborns, video-EEG helps limit misdiagnosis.
Yes, and atypical symptoms make them a diagnostic challenge. A claim looks at what was reported, what imaging was done and what treatment could have changed.
In general, pediatric neurology expert fees are determined by the expert themselves, based on a variety of criteria. Among those criteria are experience, the length of the child's history, imaging and EEG review, whether an examination is needed and the amount of testimony. Vident does have some influence over expert fees by comparing experts within a specialty, but ultimately it is a personal decision by the expert.
Related Insights
Neurology, the branch of medicine that deals with the diagnosis and treatment of disorders of the nervous system, encompasses many subspecialties, but there is no consensus as to what they are. The...
Case AnalysisMost of us have signed a hospital consent form without reading every word. A recent Vermont Supreme Court decision, Ford v. Polomsky, shows what can happen when a patient later says, "I never agreed t...
Practice Area IntelligenceOver the past several years I have reviewed medical charts for both insurance companies and pain clinics to determine if what has been recorded makes good medical sense and shows an appropriate level...
Sources
Vident Partners connects attorneys with qualified pediatric neurology expert witnesses. Complimentary consultation, 24-hour turnaround, no obligation.
Request an Expert →