Vident Partners provides vetted child custody and parenting evaluation expert witnesses for cases involving best interests assessments, parenting plans, review of a custody evaluator's work, relocation, intimate partner violence, alienating behaviors, and adoption or third-party visitation disputes nationwide. Request a referral today.
Find a Child Custody & Parenting Evaluation Expert →Overview
A child custody expert helps a family court understand what a child needs, what each parent can provide, and how well the two fit. The expert informs the judge's decision, and the judge makes it. Two very different roles carry the label: an evaluator who meets the family and reports to the court, and a consultant who reviews someone else's evaluation. Choosing the wrong one is an early and expensive mistake. Child protection work is a separate field, covered on the child welfare page.
The standard is usually the best interests of the child. The American Psychological Association's guidelines note that best interests is defined in many state statutes and that the legal standard generally reflects criteria related to the circumstances of the child and of the parent or caregiver 1. So the expert must begin with the factors in the governing statute, not a general theory of good parenting.
The Constitution sets an outer boundary. In Troxel v. Granville, a plurality concluded that a Washington visitation statute, as applied, violated a mother's due process right to make decisions concerning the care, custody and control of her daughters 2. That matters most in grandparent and third-party claims. When a state moves to end parental rights altogether, Santosky v. Kramer requires at least clear and convincing evidence 3. Jurisdiction can matter as much as merits. Federal law requires every state to enforce a custody or visitation determination made consistently with the statute by a court of another state, and limits modification 4.
The APA adopted revised Guidelines for Child Custody Evaluations in Family Law Proceedings as policy in February 2022, and the Association of Family and Conciliation Courts publishes Guidelines for Parenting Plan Evaluations in Family Law Cases, dated 2022 1 5. Neither is a law, and the APA says they are aspirational and do not cover every course of action 1. They are still the usual yardstick on cross-examination.
A reviewer tests an evaluation against points like these:
The hardest cases involve safety. The APA guidelines say psychologists strive to identify the presence and potential consequences of child abuse, child neglect, intimate partner violence and various pathogenic parenting practices, including loyalty binding, enmeshment, role reversal and alienating behaviors, using scientific evidence and ethical practices 1. They also seek to recognize the effect of high-conflict divorce 1. These allegations can cross, since one parent may report abuse while the other reports alienation. An expert should explain how each claim was tested. A label should not take the place of the data, and courts vary in how they receive alienation testimony, so counsel should check the forum's cases.
The APA guidelines state that they are not intended for psychologists functioning in a consultant role or as a non-evaluating investigator 1. A court-appointed evaluator has wide access to the family. A retained reviewer usually has neither, and should not offer opinions about parents never examined. The reviewer's proper subject is the method and the reliability of the evaluation. Rule 702 asks whether the opinion reflects a reliable application of principles and methods to the facts 6, although state family courts may apply their own standards.
Most evaluators are licensed psychologists, psychiatrists or social workers with specific forensic and child development training. Ask how many evaluations the expert has completed, for which courts, and how the state regulates evaluators, because some courts and states set their own training requirements. Check that the license covers the work in that state. For young children, ask about training in infant and early childhood development. Add a pediatrician, a child psychiatrist or a forensic interviewer where abuse is alleged. A vocational or financial expert may address support, and a domestic violence expert may address safety and dynamics.
The American Psychological Association's 2022 guidelines call for assessing each parent's capacity and functioning with an evidence-based, multitrait-multimethod approach.
Case Types
Contested custody and parenting time disputes
Review of a court-appointed custody evaluation
Relocation of a child with one parent
Allegations of abuse, neglect, or intimate partner violence in custody cases
Alienating behavior and resist-refuse disputes
Grandparent and third-party visitation claims
Adoption and termination of parental rights disputes
Parenting plan and modification disputes, including interstate custody
Qualifications
Related Specialties
FAQ
Most are licensed psychologists, psychiatrists, or social workers with specific forensic and child development training. Ask how many evaluations the expert has done, for which courts, and whether the state sets its own requirements. Competence in assessing abuse and intimate partner violence claims is essential.
An evaluator meets the family and reports on it, often by court appointment. A consultant reviews an evaluation for a party. The APA's guidelines say they are not intended for psychologists in a consultant role. A reviewer should address method and reliability and should not offer opinions about parents never examined.
Usually the best interests of the child, which many state statutes define. The APA's guidelines say the standard generally reflects criteria related to the circumstances of the child and of the parent or caregiver. The expert should start with the factors in the governing statute.
That depends on state law, within a constitutional limit. In Troxel v. Granville, a plurality of the Supreme Court concluded that a Washington statute, as applied, violated a mother's due process right to make decisions about her daughters. Counsel should read the state's statute and cases since that decision.
The APA's guidelines include alienating behaviors among the parenting practices psychologists strive to identify, along with abuse, neglect, and intimate partner violence, using scientific evidence and ethical practices. An expert should show how each claim was tested. Courts vary in how they receive this testimony, so check the forum's cases.
In general, child custody expert fees are determined by the expert themselves, based on a variety of criteria. Among those criteria are clinical experience, forensic experience, licensure, the scope of the evaluation, and publications. Vident does have some influence over expert fees by comparing experts within a specialty, but ultimately it is a personal decision by the expert.
Sources
Vident Partners connects attorneys with qualified child custody & parenting evaluation expert witnesses. Complimentary consultation, 24-hour turnaround, no obligation.
Request an Expert →