Vident Partners provides vetted business management expert witnesses for cases involving corporate governance, director and officer decisions, fiduciary and shareholder disputes, oversight failures, and management practice in private and public companies. Request a referral today.
Find a Business Management Expert →Overview
A business management expert decides whether the people running a company made decisions the way competent managers and directors would: what they knew, what process they used, and how the choice looked at the time. The expert explains how companies are actually governed and run. This page covers corporate governance and general management practice. Accounting belongs to an auditor, value to a valuation expert, losses to an economist, and enterprise risk programs to a risk management expert.
Corporate governance starts with structure. In Delaware, the business and affairs of a corporation are managed by or under the direction of the board 1. Directors are fully protected in relying in good faith on corporate records and on information, opinions and reports from officers, employees and committees 1. So an expert often addresses what the board was given, whether the material was adequate, and how the board used it.
The law defers to process. The expert's role is not to second-guess a business choice with hindsight. It is to compare the steps taken with what a functioning board or management team does before such a decision, such as obtaining information, asking questions, testing alternatives and recording the reasons.
Conflicts carry their own rules. Section 144 now sets out how an interested transaction, or a controlling stockholder transaction, may be protected, including approval in good faith and without gross negligence by a majority of disinterested directors after disclosure of the material facts 1. The section carries its own application note, so the expert must check the version that applies to the date and transaction. A company formed elsewhere follows its own state's law, and an LLC or partnership may follow its operating agreement instead.
Management failure cases are often oversight cases. Clovis Oncology describes the Caremark test: no one must know everything, but the board must make a good faith effort to set up an oversight system and watch it 2. In McDonald's, the court held that officers also owe a duty of oversight within their areas of responsibility 3. An expert reads organization charts, reporting lines, committee charters and board packages to see how information moved, who owned the problem and what stopped it from rising.
Public companies add formal duties. Under the Sarbanes-Oxley Act, signing officers must certify that they reviewed each report and are responsible for establishing and maintaining internal controls 4. Management must also assess those controls each year 5. Regulation S-K requires disclosure of the board's leadership structure and role in risk oversight 6. Those statements create a record a management expert can test against actual practice.
Most management cases are not public company cases. They involve closely held businesses, family companies and partnerships: disputes about a founder pushed out, a manager's use of company funds, a failed turnaround or a sale process. The documents are smaller and messier: emails, budgets, sales reports, bank statements, meeting notes if they exist. An expert can say what a reasonable manager of a business of that size would have done, and how a sound process would have looked, while being careful not to hold a small company to a big company's formality.
Experience counts as a basis under Rule 702, but only if the expert shows the link. The committee note asks the witness to explain how the experience produced the conclusion and why it fits these facts 7. A bare statement of custom will not do. A strong report points to the company's own plans and policies, comparable companies, and published governance standards.
No license exists for managers or directors. Look for a person who has held the seat at issue at a comparable company: a chief executive, chief operating officer, public company director or turnaround manager. Academic researchers in management can add context on governance practice, but a court will ask what they have actually done or studied that fits these facts. Match the industry and size where possible. Legal conclusions, such as whether a fiduciary duty was breached, stay with the court.
Delaware says the business and affairs of a corporation are managed by or under the direction of the board, and directors are fully protected in relying in good faith on corporate records and reports.
Case Types
Shareholder and partner disputes over management decisions
Director and officer breach of duty claims
Conflicted and controlling stockholder transactions
Oversight failures and missed red flags
Founder removal and closely held company disputes
Failed turnarounds and business collapses
Sale process and board decision making
Executive misconduct and internal investigations
Qualifications
Related Specialties
FAQ
There is no license for managers. Look for someone who has held the seat at issue at a comparable company, such as a chief executive, operating officer or director. Academic researchers can add context, but a court will ask how their work fits the facts.
Hindsight is the wrong frame. The more useful opinion compares the board's process with what a functioning board does: what it knew, what it asked and how it recorded the decision. Whether a duty was breached is a legal conclusion for the court.
In McDonald's, the Delaware Court of Chancery held that officers owe a duty of oversight. An officer's duty to address and report red flags generally applies within the officer's area, though a particularly egregious red flag may require speaking up outside it. A breach requires bad faith.
No. An expert should measure a closely held business against what a reasonable manager of a company that size would do, along with its own agreements and state law. Formal public company rules such as Sarbanes-Oxley apply to issuers, not to most private companies.
Section 144 of the Delaware General Corporation Law sets out how an interested or controlling stockholder transaction may be protected, including approval by disinterested directors or stockholders. The section carries an application note, so the expert should confirm it applies to the transaction and date.
In general, management expert fees are determined by the expert themselves, based on a variety of criteria. Among those criteria are professional experience, forensic experience, industry background, academic qualifications, and publications. Vident does have some influence over expert fees by comparing experts within a specialty, but ultimately it is a personal decision by the expert.
Related Insights
In January we posted a summary review of the Johnson & Johnson (J&J) baby powder litigation. A striking new development warrants an update: Judge Christopher Lopez of the U.S. Bankruptcy Court for...
Practice Area IntelligenceMedicare and Medicaid fraud represent a significant challenge to the financial integrity of the United States healthcare system. The real cost of such fraudulent activities is multifaceted,...
Practice Area IntelligenceAccountants play a key role in litigation by providing a range of specialized services that can support the legal process. Their expertise in financial matters allows them to offer insights and...
Sources
Vident Partners connects attorneys with qualified business management expert witnesses. Complimentary consultation, 24-hour turnaround, no obligation.
Request an Expert →